Sex and Gender Identifications in the View of Islam and Western Thought
A Comparative Narrative on Gender Ambiguity Debates
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.33102/jfatwa.vol30no3.698Keywords:
Sex, gender, identification, gender dysphoria, MalaysiaAbstract
Contemporary debates on gender identity reveal a fundamental divergence between Islamic and Western perspectives, creating significant theoretical and practical tensions in addressing gender ambiguity. Islam upholds a binary framework where biological sex determines gender identity, while Western thought increasingly separates sex from gender, recognizing gender as a social construct independent of biological markers. This ideological divide raises critical issues regarding gender dysphoria management, gender transition legitimacy, and accommodation of gender-variant individuals within different societal frameworks. This study conducts a comparative analysis of Islamic jurisprudence and Western gender theory through qualitative content analysis of religious texts, scholarly works, medical literature, and policy documents to examine how each tradition addresses gender identification conflicts. The research investigates theoretical foundations and practical applications of both approaches to gender-related disorders and identity crises. Key findings reveal that while Islam maintains consistent binary classifications rooted in biological determinism since the Quranic era, it demonstrates flexibility in addressing intersex conditions through established jurisprudential mechanisms. Despite fundamental philosophical differences, the study concludes that potential convergence areas exist between Islamic principles and certain medical interventions, suggesting possibilities for nuanced dialogue rather than absolute opposition in addressing contemporary gender identity challenges and fostering cross-cultural understanding.
Downloads
References
Abdulssalam, A. S. (2006). Gender and sexuality: An Islamic perspective. SARI: Jurnal Alam dan Tamadun Melayu, 24, 34-48.
Al-Ayni, M. A. M. A. H. (2000). Al-Binaya Sharh Al-Hidaya. Dar Al-Kutub Al-Ilmiyya.
Al-Babarti, M. M. M. (n.d.). Al-Inaya Sharh Al-Hidaya. Dar Al-Fikr.
Al-Bukhari, M. I. I. (2009). Sahih al-Bukhari. Riyad: Dar al-Salam.
Al-Sarakhsi, M. I. A. (1993). Al-Mabsut. Beirut: Dar al-Ma‘rifah.
Al-Sayyid Salam, A. M. K. (2010). Sahih Fiqh al-Sunnah. Cairo: Dar al-Tawfiqiah li al-Turath.
Al-Tabari, M. I. J. (2012). Jami‘ al-Bayan fī Ta’wil ay al-Qur’an. Damascus: Dar al-Qalam.
Al-Zuhayli, W. (2013). Mawsu‘ah al-Fiqh al-Islami wa al-Qadaya al-Mu‘asirah. Beirut: Dar al-Fikr.
Arnold, A. P. (2004). Sex chromosomes and brain gender. Nature Reviews Neuroscience, 5, 1-8.
Bonifacio, J. H., Maser, C., Stadelman, K., & Palmert, M. (2019). Management of gender dysphoria in adolescents in primary care. Cmaj, 191(3), E69-E75.
Butina, M. (2015). A narrative approach to qualitative inquiry. Clinical laboratory science, 28(3), 190-196.
Capetillo-Ventura, N. C., Jalil-Pérez, S. I., & Motilla-Negrete, K. (2015). Gender dysphoria: An overview. Medicina Universitaria, 17(66), 53-58.
Coleman, E., Bockting, W., Botzer, M., Cohen-Kettenis, P., DeCuypere, G., Feldman, J., & Zucker, K. (2012). Standards of care for the health of transsexual, transgender, and gender-nonconforming people, version 7. International journal of transgenderism, 13(4), 165-232.
Cooper, K., Russell, A., Mandy, W., & Butler, C. (2020). The phenomenology of gender dysphoria in adults: A systematic review and meta-synthesis. Clinical Psychology Review, 80, Article 101875.
Davis, G., Dewey, J. M., & Murphy, E. L. (2016). Giving Sex: Deconstructing Intersex and Trans Medicalization Practices. Gender & Society, 30(3), 490-514.
Dessouky, N. (2001). Gender assignment for children with intersex problems: An Egyptian perspective. Egyptian Journal of Surgery, 20, 499–515.
Eagly, A. H. (1987). Sex differences in social behavior: A social-role interpretation (1st ed.). Psychology Press.
Ecare. (2024). Gender dysphoria: Understanding the condition and its mental health treatments.
Entwistle, J. (1998). Sex/gender. In Core sociological dichotomies (pp. 151-165).
Francoeur, R. T., & Hendrixson, L. L. (1999). Human sexuality. In Handbook of marriage and the family (pp. 743-766). Boston, MA: Springer US.
Germon, J. (2009). Gender: a genealogy of an idea. Springer.
Gill-Peterson, J. (2018). Histories of the transgender child. U of Minnesota Press.
Haneef, S. S. S., & Zahir, A. A. (2016). Gender Categorization between Islam and Science: The Problem of Integration from Islamic Jurisprudence Perspective. Revelation and Science, 6(1).
Hanna, B., Desai, R., Parekh, T., Guirguis, E., Kumar, G., & Sachdeva, R. (2019). Psychiatric disorders in the US transgender population. Annals of epidemiology, 39, 1-7.
Hines, M. (2020). Human gender development. Neuroscience & Biobehavioral Reviews, 118, 89-96.
Ibn Nujaym, Z. I. M. (n.d.). Al-Bahr Al-Ra'iq Sharh Kanz Al-Daqa'iq (2nd ed.). Dar Al-Kitab Al-Islami.
Ibn Qudamah, M. I. ‘A. I. A. (2004). Al-Mughni. Cairo: Dar al-Hadith.
Ibn Qudamah, M. I. ‘A. I. A. (2010). Al-Kāfī fī Fiqh al-Imām Aḥmad bin Ḥanbal. Beirut: Dar Ibn Hazm.
Jacobs, M. D. (2011). Western history: What's gender got to do with it? Faculty Publications, Department of History, 114.
Jamneankal, T., Kiatrungrit, K., & Arunakul, J. (2023). Validity and reliability of the Thai version of the Utrecht Gender Dysphoria Scale-Gender Spectrum (UGDS-GS) in Thai youths and young adults with gender dysphoria. General Psychiatry, 36, Article e100980.
Kaltiala-Heino, R., Bergman, H., Työläjärvi, M., & Frisén, L. (2018). Gender dysphoria in adolescence: Current perspectives. Adolescent Health, Medicine and Therapeutics, 9, 31-41.
Levy, D. (2006). Qualitative methodology and grounded theory in property research. Pacific Rim Property Research Journal, 12(4), 369-388.
Mohd Zainudin, M. (2024). Gender dysphoria. In Centris (Chapter 3).
Morgenroth, T., Sendén, M. G., Lindqvist, A., Renström, E. A., Ryan, M. K., & Morton, T. A. (2021). Defending the sex/gender binary: The role of gender identification and need for closure. Social Psychological and Personality Science, 12(5), 731-740.
Özbey, H., Darendeliler, F., Kayserili, H., Korkmazlar, Ü., & Salman, T. (2004). Gender assignment in female congenital adrenal hyperplasia: A difficult experience. BJU International, 94(3), 388–391.
Rey, R., Josso, N., & Racine, C. (2020). Sexual differentiation. In K. R. Feingold, B. Anawalt, & M. R. Blackman (Eds.), Endotext. MDText.com, Inc.
Roselli, C. E. (2018). Neurobiology of gender identity and sexual orientation. Journal of neuroendocrinology, 30(7), e12562.
Schneider, C., Cerwenka, S., Nieder, T. O., Briken, P., Cohen-Kettenis, P. T., De Cuypere, G., Haraldsen, I. R., Kreukels, B. P., & Richter-Appelt, H. (2016). Measuring gender dysphoria: A multicenter examination and comparison of the Utrecht Gender Dysphoria Scale and the Gender Identity/Gender Dysphoria Questionnaire for Adolescents and Adults. Archives of Sexual Behavior, 45(3), 551-558.
Simon, W. (2017). Sexual Conduct: The Social Sources of Human Sexuality (2nd ed.). Routledge.
Taha, S. A. (1994). Male pseudohermaphroditism: Factors determining the gender of rearing in Saudi Arabia. Urology, 43, 370–374.
Wilhelm, D., & Pask, A. J. (2018). Gametogenesis, fertilization and early development. In Encyclopedia of Reproduction (2nd ed.).
Wu, Q., Li, N., Li, W., Li, T., Zhang, C., Cui, Y., & Zhai, J. (2014). Clinical, molecular and cytogenetic analysis of 46, XX testicular disorder of sex development with SRY-positive. BMC Urology, 14, Article 70.
Yama, P., & Dehis, N. H. B. (2018). Perbezaan Khunsa dan Mukhannath menurut Perspektif Al-Quran dan Al-Sunnah. In Proceeding of The International Conference On Contemporary Issues In Al-Quran And Hadith (pp. 72-77).
Zucker, K. J., Lawrence, A. A., & Kreukels, B. P. (2016). Gender dysphoria in adults. Annual review of clinical psychology, 12(1), 217-247.
Downloads
Published
Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 2025 Ahmad Akram Mahmad Robbi, Sayyed Mohamed Muhsin, Mohamad Mohiuddin Mahi, Mohd Fuad Md. Sawari, Khairul Fahmi Jamaludin
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.
The copyright of this article will be vested to author(s) and granted the journal right of first publication with the work simultaneously licensed under the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International (CC BY 4.0) license, unless otherwise stated.
How to Cite
